Chapter 4

Differential Relations for Fluid Flow

table of content

Oblique Shocks and Expansion Waves


Overview

In real life supersonic flow applications, normal shocks as the ones studied in Chapter 3 appear in very specific situations only. The situation will rather be that a complex shock pattern built up of combinations of oblique shocks, expansion waves and slip lines will be formed. The nature and geometry of the generated shocks formed around an object depends on flow Mach number and the geometry of the object.

Sections

4.2 Source of Oblique Waves

Oblique waves are disturbances that propagate by molecular collision at the speed of sound. Oblique waves may eventually coalesce and form oblique shocks or spread out to form an expansion wave.

The formation of Mach waves is described. The Mach wave angle is dependent on the free stream Mach number. The relation between the free stream Mach number and the Mach angle is illustrated in Figure 1 below.



Mach wave
Figure 1: Mach waves

4.3 Oblique Shock Relations

The governing equations for an oblique shock are derived and, by coordinate transformation, it turns out that we can use most of the relations obtained for normal shocks in the shock-normal direction. Deriving the governing equations in the shock-normal direction and the direction along the oblique shock it is shown that the velocity in the direction along the shock is preserved over the shock.

Control volume for derivation of the oblique shock relations
Figure 2: The oblique shock relations are derived using a control volume approach

The \(\theta-\beta-M\)-relation is derived, which proves to be very important in the investigation of oblique shocks. The expression relates the free stream Mach number \(M\), the deflection angle \(\theta\), and the oblique shock angle \(\beta\). From the relation, it is obvious that each situation has two possible solutions one with a lower \(\beta\) angle that is referred to as the weak solution and one with a larger angle \(\beta\) that is referred to as the strong solution. In nature, the weak solution is preferred over the strong solution due to less losses. However, in some cases the strong solution may be the only solution possible due to downstream flow conditions.

theta-beta-Mach relation
Figure 3: The \(\theta-\beta-M\)-relation relates deflection angle, shock angle, and Mach number ahead of the shock

4.4 Supersonic Flows Over Wedges and Cones

The generation of oblique shocks is illustrated by the examples of flow over wedges (two-dimensional flow) and cones (three-dimensional flow). It is shown how the oblique shock relations can be used to calculate the flow properties on the downstream side of an oblique shock given the free stream Mach number and the cone angle (the deflection angle).

4.5 Shock Polar

The shock polar constitutes a graphical tool that can be used to analyze and understand a oblique shock situation.

4.6 Regular Reflection from a Solid Boundary

What happens when an oblique shock reaches a wall? Will the shock reflect and, in case it does, how will it reflect?

This section gives examples where there is a need for another oblique shock to be generated at the point where a first oblique shock reaches a wall in a channel configuration in order to deflect the flow such that it is aligned with the downstream wall. Since the incoming Mach number will not be the same, the angle of the oblique shocks will be different even if the deflection angle is the same. This means that the oblique shock is not specularly deflected.

Regular reflection
Figure 4: Regular shock reflection at a solid boundary

4.7 Comment on Flow Through Multiple Shock Systems

As oblique shocks generates less losses than normal shocks, a system of consecutive oblique shocks is, if possible, a solution preferred by nature (and engineers) over a single normal shock at all times. In some situations, however, no oblique shock solutions exists and thus a normal shock is the only alternative.

4.8 Pressure-Deflection Diagrams

The pressure-deflection diagram is yet another graphical tool used to analyze systems of shocks. In this section it is illustrated how a pressure-deflection diagram can be used to visualize the shock reflection at solid boundaries discussed in the previous section.

4.9 Intersection of Shocks of Opposite Families

More complex examples involving oblique shocks are introduced. What happens when left and right running shocks intersects?

The slip line concept is introduced. A slip line is a discontinuity in flow and thermodynamic quantities over which pressure and flow angle are continuous. A slip line can appear between two flow regions with the same flow direction where the fluid in the two regions has passed different shock systems on its way there. Passing different shock systems implies that the losses introduced are different and so is the flow Mach number, temperature, density.

Slip line
Figure 5: Slip lines are discontinuities in flow and thermodynamic quantities over which pressure and flow angle are continuous

Again the pressure-deflection diagram is used to illustrate the shock system graphically.

4.10 Intersection of Shocks of the Same Families

It is shown that Mach waves generated at the upstream or downstream side of an oblique shock will intersect with the shock at some point. Intersection of shocks of the same family is also discussed.

Wave intersection
Figure 6: Intersection of waves of the same family

4.11 Mach Reflection

Regular shock reflection as discussed in section 4.6 is possible only if the \(\theta-\beta-M\)-relation has a solution for the given Mach number and deflection angle. If that is not the case, we will instead get a Mach reflection at the solid wall. This means that a normal shock is formed at the wall that away from the wall bends of to match the angle of the oblique shock. To be able to analyze the flow in a Mach reflection case we will need to use CFD.

Mach reflection
Figure 7: Mach reflection

4.12 Detached Shock Wave in Front of a Blunt Body

In front of a blunt body, generation of oblique shocks is not possible and instead we will get a detached bow shock. In front of the object, the detached shock is normal generating a region of subsonic flow in front of the object. Away from the object, the shock bends of and becomes an oblique shock, which means that the flow behind the shock may very well be supersonic downstream of the shock. This gives us a transonic flow situation, i.e. a supersonic flow field with small regions of subsonic flow.

Detached shock
Figure 8: Detached shock in front of a blunt body in supersonic free stream

4.14 Prandtl-Meyer Expansion Waves

Expansion waves are in many ways the antithesis of shock waves. They arise when a supersonic flow is turned away from itself. An expansion region is built up of an infinite number of weak Mach waves. Since each Mach wave is isentropic the entire expansion region is isentropic, which means that the isentropic relations may be used over the expansion region.
over an expansion region we will get an increase in flow Mach number, decrease in pressure, decrease in density and decrease in temperature.

Starting from a geometrical analyze of the slight change in flow angle over one single Mach wave and assuming calorically perfect gas, the Prandtl-Meyer function is derived. The Prandtl-Meyer function can be used to obtain the downstream flow Mach number after a expansion region given the upstream Mach number and deflection angle.

Prandtl-Meyer expansion
Figure 9: Prandtl-Meyer expansion fan

4.15 Shock-Expansion Theory

Shock expansion theory is nothing else but the analysis of flow situations including both shock waves and expansion waves. As an example the flow over a diamond wedge is analyzed and also the flow over a flat plate at an angle of attack. Using the oblique shock relations and the Prandtl-Meyer function we are able to obtain pressures on all surfaces of the diamond wedge and flat plate and thus lift and drag forces can be calculated.

Shock-expansion theory
Figure 10: Shock-expansion theory - flow around a diamond-shaped wedge



Study Guide

The questions below are intended as a "study guide" and may be helpful when reading the text book.


  1. What is the difference between the control volume in an integral formulation and a differential formulation of the governing equations?
  2. Rewrite the acceleration using the chain rule and group the terms into local acceleration terms and convective acceleration terms
  3. Explain the physical meaning of the local acceleration term and the convective acceleration term
  4. The continuity equation on differential form:
    1. Derive the continuity equation on differential form starting from the integral form for a fixed control volume $$\int_{cv}\dfrac{\partial \rho}{\partial t}d\mathcal{V}+\sum_i\left(\rho_iA_iV_i\right)_{out}-\sum_i\left(\rho_iA_iV_i\right)_{in}=0$$ and let the size of the control volume reduce to infinitesimal size
    2. How can we simplify the continuity equation on differential form under the following circumstances? $$\dfrac{\partial \rho}{\partial t}+\dfrac{\partial (\rho u)}{\partial x}+\dfrac{\partial (\rho v)}{\partial y}+\dfrac{\partial (\rho w)}{\partial z}=0$$
      1. steady-state flow
      2. incompressible flow
  5. The momentum equation on differential form:
    1. Derive the momentum equation on differential form starting from the integral form $$\sum\mathbf{F}=\dfrac{d}{dt}\left(\int_{cv}\mathbf{V}\rho d\mathcal{V}\right)+\sum\left(\dot{m}_i\mathbf{V}_i\right)_{out}-\sum\left(\dot{m}_i\mathbf{V}_i\right)_{in}$$ and let the size of the control volume reduce to infinitesimal size
    2. A fluid element is subjected to both body forces and surface forces. Give an example of a body force and name the two surface forces.
    3. Make a sketch of a control volume used for the derivation of the governing equations on differential form and indicate the stresses acting on the surfaces of the cube in one selected direction. Write down the resulting surface force in the selected direction.
    4. What generates the stresses denoted \(\tau_{ij}\). What is the difference between \(\tau_{ij}\) and \(\sigma_{ij}\).
  6. The \(x\)-component of the Navier-Sokes equations reads: $$\dfrac{\partial u}{\partial t}+u\dfrac{\partial u}{\partial x}+v\dfrac{\partial u}{\partial y}+w\dfrac{\partial u}{\partial z}=g_x-\dfrac{1}{\rho}\dfrac{\partial p}{\partial x}+\dfrac{\mu}{\rho}\left(\dfrac{\partial^2 u}{\partial x^2}+\dfrac{\partial^2 u}{\partial y^2}+\dfrac{\partial^2 u}{\partial z^2}\right)$$ What is the physical meaning of each of the terms in the equation?
  7. Under what circumstances can the general formulation of the momentum equation be reduced to the Navier-Stokes equation?
  8. If the integral angular momentum equation is applied to a control volume and the control volume is reduced to infinitesimal size, one will see a special feature of the stress tensor \(\tau_{ij}\). What feature is that?
  9. What is the physical meaning of the terms in the simplified energy equation? $$\rho C_v\dfrac{dT}{dt}=k\nabla^2T+\Phi$$
  10. Simplify the following system of equations for incompressible flow. Use the relation between the stress tensor and velocity derivatives applicable for Newtonian fluids. $$\dfrac{\partial \rho}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\rho \mathbf{V}\right)=0$$ $$\rho\dfrac{d\mathbf{V}}{dt}=\rho \mathbf{g}-\nabla p+\nabla\cdot \tau_{ij}$$ $$\rho \dfrac{d \hat{u}}{dt}+p\left(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{V}\right)=\nabla\cdot\left(k\nabla T\right)+\Phi$$ What unknown properties can be calculated and how many equations do we have?
  11. What boundary conditions are often used for velocity and temperature at a solid wall?
  12. 2D incompressible duct flow:
    1. Simplify the continuity equation and Navier-Stokes equations without pressure gradient driven by a moving upper wall, i.e., Couette flows.
    2. Simplify the continuity equation and Navier-Stokes equations for pressure-driven flow, i.e., Poiseuille flows.
    3. Show that the Couette flow is rotational by analyzing a small fluid element.
  13. How is vorticity defined?

Document Archive
MTF053_C04.pdf Lecture notes chapter 4
MTF053_Formulas-Tables-and-Graphs.pdf A collection of formulas, tables, and graphs



Videos


Divergence and Curl